By Ronn Burner • on April 27, 2010
The 2010 NFL draft has come and gone and the “grades” are in! I say this with more than a hint of sarcasm since at this point we really know nothing. If we did, would Dan Marino have been the 6th quarterback taken in 1983 and the 27th player selected overall? If you’re thinking about the answer to that please stop reading. You’re not a football fan, in fact, you’re not even allowed to talk about sports. Ever.
How silly does the Ryan Leaf and Peyton Manning debate sound now? I’m not going to lie; I was firmly in the Leaf corner at that time and likely the reason I’m sitting in a freezing cold office with no windows writing this instead of a War Room bragging about the notion that I outsmarted the room and found my starting free safety, a Georgia Team Captain in the 5th round while every other team passed on him… 5 times! I hope your right Bill Parcells. Keep in mind so-called NFL draft gurus Mel Kiper and Todd McShay each gave Miami a C for their draft last year, which included Vontae Davis, Sean Smith, Brian Hartline and Chris Clemons. On that scale, I would kill for a C again this year!
There are countless examples of this, yet in our insatiable hunger for immediate justification we feel compelled to grade the process that takes at least 3 to 4 years to truly gauge simply to nurture our self worth. It makes about as much sense as buying a lottery ticket and running out of the Quickie Mart screaming, “I’m rich! I’m rich!” before you even scratch it off.
I refuse to grade the selections because aside from the lunacy of it all the truth is Parcells, Jeff Ireland and Tony Sporano know a hell of a lot more than I do and I’m not going to pretend to know more than I do. Of course I have an opinion and I’m not afraid to voice it so I will. I would just take it with a grain of salt from a fan trying to figure this whole thing out the best we can from a distance.
“For the next three days we are going to draft prototypical players that play football well in their pads on the football field,” the sign in the Dolphins draft room read.
Based on their collegiate careers, that is precisely what they did. They drafted hard-nosed, hard working, high character, high motor, high IQ and quality leaders with McCoy being the only selection that was not a team captain in college.
Without further adieu, your 2010 Miami Dolphins draft picks.
Jared Odrick, 1, 28, DT, Penn St.
Scouting Report: Pass rush: Has good height, strength, agility and length to be a consistent penetrator. Bowled over many college linemen with his bull rush and seems to be in motion with the snap of the ball. Has some shiftiness and is able to penetrate with a swim or an inside-out move when blocked one-on-one. Uses his hands to discard linemen. Disrupts passing lanes with his long arms and big hands, keeping his eyes in the backfield. Can accelerate to the quarterback after initial contact but does not have elite quickness or change-of-direction ability to come back and make the sack or chase down plays in the backfield.
Run defense: Usually holds his ground inside or pushes back against double-teams. Disengages from blocks to get back into the play and has made stops four or five yards downfield. Not quick enough laterally, but uses his strength to move down the line while engaged on stretch plays. Must be more aware of protecting his knees from cut blocks.
Explosion: Good quickness and pop off the snap. Able to knock his man back a step or two into the pocket. Improved his get-off as a senior playing the three-technique and is able to consistently penetrate from that spot.
Strength: Brute strength makes him a tough assignment in pass protection for college linemen. Stacks his man and rips off in either direction to fill a hole. Pushes the pocket as a pass rusher, even when double-teamed. Plays tall but controls the line on almost every snap when straight-up or doubled.
Tackling: Solid wrap tackler inside because of his strength and length at the point. Lacks the change-of-direction ability to regularly rein in elusive ballcarriers or make plays from behind. His height also prevents him from consistently breaking down in space.
Intangibles: Work ethic and consistency of effort have been questioned in the past, but he appeared to turn a corner in 2009. Cited for disorderly conduct and fined for a February 2009 early morning fight in downtown State College.
Koa Misi, 2, 40, OLB, Utah
Scouting Report: Read & React: Very good football instincts — sniffs out screens, misdirection and cut blocks. Reads routes and knows where the hot read is in coverage. 
Run defense: Explosive coming off the edge if untouched, flexible enough to chase down backs. Lacks the bulk to play end on early downs at the next level, but is strong enough as a linebacker on the edge to be an effective run stopper. Smart on containment and takes away the cutback lane. Punches linemen coming out to block, can disengage to make a play. Gets through trash to find the ball. Excellent chase and hustle down the line or downfield.
Pass defense: Very fluid in his drops, turns hips and gets deep quickly. Will struggle getting off lineman blocks, but seems to find creases to get to the ball in traffic. Good ball awareness whether blitzing or dropped into zone coverage. Gets his hands up when unable to reach the quarterback. Beats cut blocks with his hands and agile enough to recover. Strong enough to handle tight ends on the edge but needs to improve his hand usage on the line. Hustles back to get to open receivers in zones.
Tackling: Excellent tackler, strong upper body and brings his hips to explode into ballcarriers. Breaks down in space and has the agility to rein in elusive players. Tracks down quicker players from behind in space with pure hustle. Will be a force on special teams, playing inside on coverage units.
Pass Rush/Blitz: Played mostly defensive end for the Utes, quick off the edge and plays through the whistle. When standing up, he has nice closing speed to the QB and some shiftiness to defeat running backs inside or turn the corner on lineman outside. Also uses his hands to keep lineman off balance and get around their outside shoulder. Will need counter moves and learn how to blow up blocks in the backfield.
Intangibles: Team captain. High character player praised by his coaches for work ethic. Suffered back injury in preseason practice, worked hard to miss only the first game of 2009 season.
John Jerry, 3, 73, OG, Ole Miss
Scouting Report: A king-sized lineman who plays RT on the Ole Miss offense, Jerry simply lacks the athleticism to consistently reach the corner vs. speed off the edge. He showcases good lateral mobility and redirection skills for his size but lacks the quickness to hold up on the outside in the NFL. He has the makings of a physical inline guard at the next level where he can use his power and strength to maul defenders in the run game. Jerry possesses long, strong arms and powerful hands. Once he locks on in the run game, he does a great job pumping his legs and driving defenders off the ball. He can certainly anchor at the point of attack in the pass game, and once he gets his hands on an opponent, the battle is over. He is a Leonard Davis-type guard at the next level.
A.J. Edds, 4, 119, LB, Iowa
Scouting Report: A big, thickly built linebacker, Edds displays good power inside the box and has the ability stack and shed on contact. Does a nice job extending his arms, keeping his base low and using his hands to disengage at the point of attack. Reads and reacts quickly to plays at the line of scrimmage and has the initial burst to make his way into the backfield and close on the football. Isn’t a real sudden athlete on contact but fights for every inch and does a great job playing with inside leverage and finding the football. Displaying really impressive instincts and always seems to be flowing toward the action. Exhibits surprising fluidity for his size in space and does a nice job cleanly flipping his hips and getting out of his breaks.
But he isn’t an overly explosive athlete and struggles quickly getting back up to speed when asked to turn and run down the field. Frequently asked to play in space in Iowa’s nickel packages, he possesses good body control and balance in zone coverage. Showcases the ability to bump off the line and takes a liking to really beating on the tight end off the snap. Looks like a guy who could win a spot at as strong-side linebacker in the NFL. Edds is never going to be a star, but he has the ability to beat tight ends in the run game and be a productive starter for an NFL defense.
Nolan Carroll, 5, 145, CB, Maryland
Scouting Report: An intriguing size/speed corner, Carroll is still raw and looks like a much better athlete than a defensive back at this stage. He lacks ideal footwork off the line and has a tendency to open up his hips prematurely and sidesaddle his way downfield. He struggles keeping his feet under him and can be slow to get out of his breaks. He displays good range when asked to track the ball in zone coverage. But he isn’t instinctive and doesn’t put himself in position to make many plays. Carroll missed most of the 2009 season with a broken leg and although he possesses impressive size/speed numbers, he looks like nothing more than a practice squad candidate in year one.
Reshad Jones, 5, 163, S, Georgia 
Scouting Report: Jones is a tall, good-looking strong safety who displays a sudden first step out of his stance when asked to attack downhill and generates good power on contact as a tackler. He’s a physical hitter with a strong upper body. He will go for the knockout punch too often instead of wrapping up but overall is a sound tackler when asked to close in pursuit. He’s also a good last-line defender who breaks down well and can wrap up in space. Jones is an above-average straight-line athlete for his size who gets up to full speed quickly and does a good job taking proper angles toward the ball. But he’s still a bit slow when asked to diagnose plays and lacks the second gear to make up for a false step. He showcases a natural initial bend in his stance but allows his pad level to get too high when asked to turn and run. Jones plays too leggy when trying to get back out of his breaks and struggles to stay compact with his footwork and generate a burst when trying to quickly change directions. He possesses good ball skills downfield, and once he sees the play he does a nice job tackling the ball, high-pointing the throw and coming down with the play. But too often he loses sight of the ball when trying to transition out of his breaks and lacks ideal overall ball awareness when trying to get his head around. Jones possesses an intriguing frame and above-average straight-line speed once he gets going but isn’t instinctive and fails to quickly redirect and change directions because of his elongated footwork.
Chris McCoy, 7, 212, DE, Middle Tennessee
Scouting Report: McCoy is an undersized defensive end prospect who lacks ideal girth in his lower half and struggles to hold up vs. the run game when the play comes toward him. He has a tendency to get too high on contact and is easily washed downfield. He works hard to disengage from blocks but struggles to gain inside leverage and consistently allows opposing linemen to get in on his frame. McCoy is slow to find the ball and isn’t the most instinctive defender. He’s asked to drop off into coverage at the line of scrimmage at times and looks a bit stiff off the ball.
Austin Spitler, 7, 252, LB, Ohio State
Scouting Report: An instinctive middle linebacker who possesses a good feel in coverage and knows how to find the ball, Spitler does well adjusting to the throw and possesses the ball skills to reel in the interception. But he isn’t natural when asked to redirect and lacks the kind of footwork and overall fluidity to cleanly get out of his breaks. He has a tendency to get grabby when asked to play on an island and is much more comfortable in zone coverage where he can read and react. He isn’t overly physical when asked to attack the line of scrimmage and struggles to keep his legs clean in pursuit. He displays slightly above-average range for the position but is easily knocked off balance and slowed in pursuit.
Miami also signed undrafted free agent WR’s Roberto Wallace 6’4”, 223 (San Diego State) and Marlon Moore 6’, 190 (Fresno State), DT’s Vince Oghobaase 6’5”, 302 (Duke) and Travis Ivey 6’4”, 341 (Maryland), CB’s Ross Weaver (Michigan State) and A.J. Wallace (Penn State), S Jon Amaya (Nevada) and OL Andy Levine 6’5”, 300 (FIU).
It’s easy to be thrilled and say we will have 4 immediate starters out of this draft but that’s not going to happen. Things never work out like that so I’m not going to expect that to here either. Jared Odrick will start. It’s John Jerry’s job to lose so it’s likely we have two starters right there but the truth is the best guards in mini camp and in the preseason will get the nod and it’s far from a guarantee that Jerry wins that job.
The O-line is a tremendously complicated position that requires cohesion like a dance partner. He’s NFL pedigree and talented, I hope he starts but there will be at least 3 or 4 guys with more NFL experience such as Richie Incognito that will have something to say about that. For sake of argument though, let’s say he wins the job. That’s two drafted starters — one on each side of the ball — a relatively smooth transition.
Now Koa Misi and Reshad Jones are also in position to come into camp and crack the starting the lineup and very well may do so but do we really want three rookie starters on defense? I don’t, even though it’s only one guy at each level and easier to implement than multiple players on one unit. Still, I would guess in an attempt at avoiding mental breakdowns that Misi and Jones will be weeded into the lineup rather than handed a spot. Of course, if they play their way onto the field and Sporano has no choice but to start them then so be it.
It’s a huge step from the college to the pro game both physically and mentally and to think that all four of these guys are going to come in and make an immediate impact from day one is wishful thinking to put it mildly. Law of averages.
Even if they did start would that speak more of them as talented rookies or the lack of talent currently on the roster at their positions?